Proposal Crtiques

Proposal 1:
Strengths: The NY Times proposal provided a lot of details regarding their topic while introducing the problem. The proposal also provides a solution that will help solve the problem.
Weaknesses: The proposal does not really include a rationale for choosing this topic

Proposal 2:
Strengths: Introduces the problem, explains why it is important and gives a solution
Weaknesses: This proposal does not really relate to the audience? Does not address and shut down other solutions

Proposal 3:
Strengths: Introduces the solution and uses lots of references. Shuts down opponents
Weaknesses: Is not really audience oriented. Does not really argue for his proposed solution well, states other solutions a bit too much.

Ranking
1: Textbook
2: Meal Card
3. Nuclear